Tony's New York Pizza

Tony's New York Pizza, located in Greencastle, PA, has quickly become a beloved spot for pizza enthusiasts. Customers rave about the friendly and professional service, making it a welcoming environment for families. Rachael Gesell highlights the staff's kindness, particularly toward children, and praises the punctuality and delicious food, which is central to the restaurant's appeal.

Scott F's review emphasizes the excellent taste and affordability of the food, stating that it's what pizza should genuinely look and taste like. His special order was executed flawlessly, showcasing the staff's willingness to accommodate dietary needs. This family-friendly atmosphere is reinforced by community support, making it a staple in the area.

Delivery options through Masa have also received commendations, with customers like Terry H appreciating the prompt service and the arrival of their meals at the perfect temperature. With its thin New York-style pizza and excellent cheesesteak subs, Tony's offers a diverse menu that keeps patrons returning. While Jim Griffin raised concerns regarding pricing practices, the overall consensus remains positive.

In summary, Tony's New York Pizza excels in delivering both quality food and a pleasant dining experience, solidifying its reputation as one of the premier pizza establishments in the region.